Quantifier versus Poetry Stylistic impoverishment and socio-cultural estrangement of Anglo-American philosophy in the last hundred years


Συγγραφέας: Istvan Aranyosi


Istvan Aranyosi: Quantifier versus Poetry Stylistic impoverishment and socio-cultural estrangement of Anglo-American philosophy in the last hundred years (pdf, 67K)
Recent discussion, both in the academia-related popular media and in some professional academic venues, about the current state and role of mainstream Anglo-American analytic philosophy among the humanities, has revealed a certain uneasiness expressed by both champions of this approach and traditional adversaries of it regarding its perceived isolation from the other fields of humanities. The fiercer critics go as far as to claim that the image of this type of philosophizing in the contemporary world is one of a discipline that is disconnected from reality, a veritable inbreeding academic cottage industry of empty scholasticism. Though I am unsympathetic to the critics who would question the very essence of how this kind of philosophy is pursued, myself being a representative of it, I nevertheless present some admittedly sketchy but, in my opinion, interesting and revealing statistical data on the evolution of several top joumals of analytic philosophy over the last hundred years in terms of the style of papers that get published, which might also justify to some extent the above mentioned complaint against analytic philosophy.